Victorinox 8-Inch vs 10-Inch Chef’s Knife: Which Size Is Right for Your Kitchen?

The Bottom Line Up Front

For most home cooks: Get the 8-inch. It’s more maneuverable, easier to control, and handles 80% of kitchen tasks perfectly.

For high-volume prep or taller cooks (6’+ with larger hands): The 10-inch excels. It makes bulk chopping faster and gives you the reach needed for breaking down large cuts of meat or working through mountains of vegetables.

The best solution? Own both. They’re different tools for different jobs, and at under $50 each, having both gives you the right knife for every situation.

Why This Question Matters

In professional kitchen environments, knife size directly impacts efficiency, control, and fatigue levels. Using the wrong-sized knife can slow prep time by 20-30% and significantly increase hand strain.

The size of your chef’s knife isn’t about ego or what looks professional. It’s about efficiency, control, and not wearing yourself out during prep work.

Quick Comparison: 8-Inch vs 10-Inch at a Glance

The 8-Inch: The Kitchen Workhorse

What Makes the 8-Inch Perfect for Most Cooks

The Goldilocks size. Not too long, not too short. The 8-inch blade gives you enough length to work efficiently through most ingredients while maintaining the control you need for precision cuts.

Professional experience shows this knife handles:

• Mincing pounds of garlic and shallots
• Dicing onions efficiently
• Breaking down whole chickens
• Julienning vegetables
• Slicing proteins during plating

The balance point is perfect. With an 8-inch blade, the pivot point sits right where you naturally grip the knife. This means less wrist strain during extended prep sessions.

Real-World Tasks Where the 8-Inch Excels

Precision Work:

• Mincing herbs (cilantro, parsley, basil)
• Dicing shallots and garlic
• Brunoise cuts (fine dice)
• Chiffonade (leafy greens)
• Segmenting citrus

Everyday Prep:

• Dicing 1-2 onions
• Chopping bell peppers
• Slicing tomatoes
• Cutting potatoes for roasting
• Portioning chicken breasts

Protein Work:

• Breaking down whole chickens
• Trimming fat from steaks
• Portioning fish fillets
• Slicing cooked meats

Who Should Choose the 8-Inch

You’re an ideal candidate for the 8-inch if:

• You cook for 1-4 people regularly
• Your kitchen counter space is limited
• You have average-sized hands (forearm ~8 inches from elbow to wrist)
• You’re under 6 feet tall
• You value control over cutting speed
• You’re building your first serious knife collection
• You want one knife that does everything well

Specifically recommended for:

• Beginners learning proper knife technique
• Home cooks who don’t do high-volume prep
• Anyone with smaller hands or shorter stature
• Cooks working in apartment kitchens or limited spaces
• People who prioritize precision over bulk processing

The 10-Inch: The High-Volume Specialist

When the Extra Two Inches Changes Everything

In professional settings, the 10-inch blade is common on prep stations. When processing large quantities—50 pounds of onions, cases of proteins, or bulk vegetable prep—those extra two inches make the job significantly faster.

The longer blade means fewer strokes to get through large ingredients. When processing for high volume, this efficiency compounds throughout the shift.

Where the 10-Inch Truly Shines

Bulk Prep Work:

• Dicing 10+ onions at once
• Breaking down whole butternut squash
• Processing large heads of cabbage
• Mincing huge bunches of herbs
• Slicing through watermelons or large melons

Large Proteins:

• Breaking down primals (large meat cuts)
• Carving whole turkeys or roasts
• Filleting large fish (salmon, striped bass)
• Trimming briskets
• Portioning large roasts

Long Slicing Cuts:

• Slicing brisket against the grain
• Carving prime rib
• Creating long, even slices of smoked salmon
• Cutting large focaccia or bread loaves

The Trade-Offs You Need to Know

The 10-inch requires more skill. The longer blade means the tip is farther from your grip point. For detail work—like mincing garlic or brunoise cuts—you need better technique to maintain control.

You need more space. A 10-inch knife requires at least 14-16 inches of clear cutting board space for comfortable use. In a cramped kitchen with limited counter space, this knife will feel awkward.

It’s heavier. At around 8 ounces compared to the 8-inch’s 6 ounces, you’ll feel the extra weight during extended use. Without proper experience, this can lead to wrist fatigue.

The learning curve is steeper. Beginners often struggle with the 10-inch because it requires more deliberate movements and better cutting technique.

Who Should Choose the 10-Inch

The 10-inch is your knife if:

• You’re over 6 feet tall with forearms 9+ inches long
• You regularly cook for 6+ people
• You do meal prep for the week in one session
• You have ample counter and cutting board space
• You frequently work with large cuts of meat
• You’ve mastered basic knife skills and want more efficiency
• You’re doing professional or catering work

Specifically recommended for:

• Experienced home cooks ready to level up
• Anyone who does bulk meal preparation
• Taller cooks who find 8-inch knives feel "small"
• Home cooks who frequently break down whole chickens, turkeys, or large roasts
• People with large hands who want more blade to grip

The Forearm Test: A Professional’s Sizing Method

Here’s the test used in professional kitchens to determine ideal knife size:

Step 1: Measure your forearm from the inside of your elbow to your wrist.

Step 2: Match that measurement to your knife blade length (not including the handle).

General Guidelines:

• Forearm 7-8 inches: Go with the 8-inch knife
• Forearm 9-10 inches: You can comfortably handle either, but the 10-inch will feel natural
• Forearm 6 inches or less: Consider a 6-inch chef’s knife or Santoku

Why this works: When the blade length matches your forearm length, the knife’s balance point naturally aligns with your grip, giving you optimal control and reducing fatigue.

Exception to this rule: Even if your forearm says "10-inch," if you’re cooking in a small kitchen with limited counter space, the 8-inch will be more practical for daily use.

The Tasks That Reveal the Difference

Specific scenarios where the size difference really matters:

Scenario 1: Dicing 5 Onions

With the 8-inch:

• Takes about 10-12 minutes
• Excellent control for consistent dice
• More comfortable for the entire task
• Easier to work in standard kitchen space

With the 10-inch:

• Takes about 7-9 minutes
• Longer blade means fewer strokes per onion
• Requires more board space for efficient rocking motion
• Better if you’re doing this volume regularly

Winner: 10-inch for speed, 8-inch for most home cooks’ comfort level

Scenario 2: Mincing 1/4 Cup Fresh Herbs

With the 8-inch:

• Perfect for this task
• Tip stays close to your hand for control
• Quick direction changes for fine mince
• Feels natural and intuitive

With the 10-inch:

• Works, but tip is farther away
• Requires more deliberate technique
• Can feel unwieldy for small-volume work
• Extra length isn’t an advantage here

Winner: 8-inch, hands down

Scenario 3: Breaking Down a Whole Chicken

With the 8-inch:

• Totally capable
• Blade length is sufficient for all cuts
• Good control through joints
• Takes about 3-4 minutes with practice

With the 10-inch:

• Slightly faster (2-3 minutes)
• Extra reach helps with separating legs
• Better leverage for cutting through thicker joints
• Preferred in professional settings

Winner: 10-inch has the edge, but 8-inch absolutely works

Scenario 4: Slicing a Beef Brisket

With the 8-inch:

• Functional but requires sawing motion
• Blade isn’t quite long enough for single-stroke slices
• Can produce less uniform slices
• Adequate for home use

With the 10-inch:

• One smooth stroke per slice
• Produces uniform, professional slices
• Significantly faster
• This is what the extra length was made for

Winner: 10-inch, no contest

Kitchen Space Considerations

Your kitchen layout matters more than most people realize when choosing knife size.

Apartment/Small Kitchen (8-Inch Recommended)

If your counter space is limited or you’re working with standard cutting boards (12x18 inches), the 8-inch is your better option. Here’s why:

Limited counter space: The 10-inch requires 14-16 inches of clear board space to use the full rocking motion effectively. In tight quarters, you’ll constantly feel cramped.

Standard cutting boards: Most home cutting boards are 12x18 inches or smaller. An 8-inch knife works perfectly on these dimensions. A 10-inch will overhang, making proper technique difficult.

Shared prep space: If you cook with a partner in a small kitchen, two people with 10-inch knives will be bumping into each other constantly.

Large Kitchen/Ample Space (Either Works)

In a kitchen with island counter space, large cutting boards (18x24 inches), and room to spread out:

Choose based on hand size and cooking volume rather than space constraints. The 10-inch will feel liberating rather than cramped.

Multiple stations: If you have space to set up multiple prep areas, you can use both knives simultaneously for different tasks.

What Professional Chefs Actually Use

Professional chefs don’t all use 10-inch knives.

By Station:

Sauté/Garde Manger (Cold station):

• Mostly 8-inch knives
• Precision matters more than speed
• Limited station space

Prep Cooks:

• Almost exclusively 10-inch
• Processing volume is their primary job
• Working at large prep tables with space

Sous Chef:

• Often owns both
• Switches based on task
• Uses 10-inch for bulk work, 8-inch for plating and precision

By Hand Size:

• Cooks under 5’8": Predominantly use 8-inch
• Cooks 5’8"-6’2": Split between both sizes
• Cooks over 6’2": Mostly use 10-inch

The pattern: There’s no "professional standard." Experienced cooks choose based on their physical dimensions and specific tasks.

The Honest Buying Recommendation

Start Here:

Buy the 8-inch first. Use it exclusively for 6-12 months. Master proper technique, build confidence, understand its limitations.

Then Evaluate:

Ask yourself these questions:

1. Do I regularly prepare food for 6+ people?
2. Do I frequently buy whole proteins (chickens, roasts) to break down?
3. Does the 8-inch feel small in my hand?
4. Do I have adequate counter/board space for a 10-inch?
5. Am I doing bulk meal prep regularly?

If you answered "yes" to 3+ questions: Add the 10-inch

If you answered "no" to most questions: Stick with your 8-inch and invest in other tools (paring knife, bread knife, quality cutting board)

The Both-Knives Scenario:

If you already know you cook in high volume, have the space, and the budget allows—buying both from the start is completely reasonable. They’re different tools that excel at different jobs.

Total investment for both knives: Complete knife size versatility for every kitchen task

Common Questions Answered

Can’t I just use one size for everything?

Yes. Millions of home cooks use only an 8-inch and cook perfectly well. The 10-inch is an efficiency upgrade, not a necessity.

If you only own one chef’s knife your entire life, the 8-inch is the better choice for versatility.

Will the 10-inch make me a better cook?

No. A 10-inch makes certain tasks faster and easier, but technique matters infinitely more than blade length.

A skilled cook with an 8-inch will outperform a beginner with a 10-inch every single time.

I’m 5’10" with average hands—which should I get?

Start with the 8-inch. At your height with average hands, you’re right in the middle zone where either knife could work. The 8-inch is more forgiving for learning and more versatile for mixed tasks.

Add the 10-inch later if you find yourself doing a lot of bulk prep.

Do I need both if I have a full knife set?

Most knife sets include redundant sizes you don’t need. If your set has a 7", 8", and 9" chef’s knife, you definitely don’t need to add a 10-inch.

But if you only have an 8-inch and you’re doing a lot of bulk work, the 10-inch is a better addition than most other specialty knives.

What about a 12-inch chef’s knife?

Skip it for home use. A 12-inch requires even more space and technique. It’s primarily used in professional settings for breaking down large primals or carving stations.

The jump from 8" to 10" is useful. The jump from 10" to 12" is rarely justified for home cooking.

The Bottom Line: What to Buy

If you’re buying your first chef’s knife:

Get the 8-inch. It’s more versatile, easier to learn, and handles 80% of cooking tasks perfectly.

If you already own an 8-inch and want to expand:

Evaluate based on actual need:

• Doing bulk prep regularly? → Add the 10-inch
• Missing detail work? → Add a paring knife instead
• Struggling with bread? → Add a bread knife instead
• Working with bone-in proteins? → Add a boning knife instead

If you want the complete solution:

Buy both. You get complete size versatility for every kitchen task. Use the 8-inch for 70% of work, the 10-inch for specific bulk and carving tasks.

More Kitchen Knife Guides