December 21, 2025 • Updated: December 21, 2025

Air Fryer vs Toaster Oven: Which Countertop Appliance Deserves Your Kitchen Space?

By Scott Bradley•24 years professional kitchen experience•12 min read

Deciding between an air fryer and a toaster oven is one of the most common dilemmas for anyone upgrading their countertop appliances. While both devices can crisp, bake, and reheat your favorite foods, they use different cooking technologies and excel at different tasks.

Understanding how these appliances compare will help you choose the right one for your cooking needs, budget, and available counter space.

The Quick Answer

Choose Air Fryer If:

You prioritize crispy, fried-style foods
Fastest cooking times matter most
You cook for 1-4 people regularly
Counter space is limited
Easy cleanup is important
You want the most affordable option

Choose Toaster Oven If:

You need versatile cooking functions including toasting
Larger capacity for families or batch cooking matters
You frequently bake or roast larger items
Quieter operation is preferred
You don't mind slightly slower cooking times
You want to consolidate multiple appliances

Keep reading for detailed performance testing and professional insights.

Air Fryer vs Toaster Oven: At a Glance

Feature	Air Fryer	Toaster Oven
Cooking Speed	30-50% faster Concentrated heat, intense airflow	Slower Requires preheating, gentler heat
Crispiness	Excellent Mimics deep-frying results	Good Less intense browning
Versatility	Limited Focused on air frying	Excellent Bake, broil, toast, roast, and more
Capacity	1-4 servings Compact basket design	4-9 servings Fits 12-inch pizza, whole chicken
Energy Efficiency	More efficient Faster cooking, no preheat	Less efficient Longer cook times
Noise Level	Noticeable Powerful fan noise	Quiet Minimal fan noise
Cleaning	Easy Dishwasher-safe baskets	More effort More components to clean
Price Range	$50-$200 Budget-friendly	$40-$400+ Wide range based on features

Detailed Comparison: What Actually Matters

Cooking Technology: How They Work Differently

Air Fryer Technology

Air fryers use intensified convection technology, blasting hot air at high speed around food in a compact chamber. This rapid air circulation creates the crispy, fried texture that makes air fryers popular for healthier versions of traditionally deep-fried foods.

Toaster Oven Technology

Toaster ovens operate more like miniature conventional ovens, using heating elements on the top and bottom to cook food. While many modern toaster ovens include convection settings with fans, these fans are typically less powerful than those in dedicated air fryers. Non-convection toaster ovens don't circulate air at all, relying purely on radiant heat.

Testing by Consumer Reports found that dedicated air fryers cook food approximately 40% faster than toaster ovens and produce noticeably crispier results. The concentrated blast of heat in an air fryer's smaller chamber allows food to crisp better and more evenly than in the larger cavity of a toaster oven.

Cooking Performance: Crispiness and Speed

Achieving Crispy Results

When it comes to achieving that coveted crispy texture, air fryers consistently outperform toaster ovens. Independent testing of chicken wings, french fries, and Brussels sprouts showed that air fryers delivered faster cooking times and crispier results across all foods tested. The compact design forces air directly through high-wattage heating elements before directing it toward food, mimicking the intense heat of deep frying.

Speed Comparison

Air fryers generally cook food 30-50% faster than toaster ovens. French fries that take 20-25 minutes in a toaster oven will be crispy in just 10-15 minutes in an air fryer. This speed advantage comes from the combination of concentrated heat, powerful airflow, and the airtight seal that most air fryers create.

Toaster ovens take longer to preheat, typically requiring 5-10 minutes to reach cooking temperature compared to air fryers that are ready almost instantly. Comprehensive testing found that while air fryer toaster ovens offer decent air frying performance, they generally fall short of basket-style air fryers for achieving faster and crispier results.

Versatility and Cooking Functions

Toaster Oven Versatility

Toaster ovens excel in versatility, offering a wider range of cooking functions than most standalone air fryers. Depending on the model, toaster ovens can air fry, bake, broil, toast, bagel, roast, dehydrate, ferment, proof dough, and even slow cook. This makes them true multi-taskers that can replace several single-purpose appliances.

The ability to toast bread is a key differentiator. If you regularly enjoy toast, bagels, or English muffins, a toaster oven handles this task effortlessly while air fryers cannot. Many users who purchased combination units report rarely using the toasting function, but it remains valuable for those who want consolidated appliances.

Air Fryer Functions

Standalone air fryers typically focus on their primary function—air frying—though many can also roast and bake. While more limited in scope, this specialization often translates to better performance at what they do. For households primarily interested in achieving crispy, fried-style foods with minimal oil, a dedicated air fryer's focused design delivers superior results.

Modern air fryer toaster oven combos attempt to bridge this gap by incorporating both technologies. Premium models combine excellent air frying with comprehensive toaster oven functionality. However, these combination units cost significantly more than standalone air fryers.

Capacity and Family Size Considerations

Toaster Oven Capacity

Toaster ovens offer substantially more cooking capacity than standard basket-style air fryers. Most air fryer toaster ovens can accommodate a 12-inch pizza, a whole chicken, or up to nine slices of bread. Some models feature 1.1 cubic feet of capacity and can fit standard casserole dishes or quarter sheet pans.

This larger capacity makes toaster ovens ideal for families or batch cooking. You can prepare enough food for 4-6 people in a single cooking session, whereas standard air fryers typically serve 2-4 people before requiring multiple batches.

Air Fryer Capacity

Traditional basket-style air fryers are more compact, with capacities ranging from 0.4 to 0.6 cubic feet for standard models. This limited space means cooking in batches for larger families, which can negate the time-saving benefits air fryers offer. However, the smaller size also means more concentrated heat and better crisping performance.

For single individuals or couples, a standard air fryer capacity is perfectly adequate for daily meals. Larger families benefit from either a high-capacity air fryer toaster oven or a dedicated toaster oven if versatility matters more than ultimate crispiness.

Energy Efficiency and Operating Costs

Energy Comparison

Air fryers are generally more energy-efficient than toaster ovens despite using higher wattage. While modern air fryers consume around 1,600W compared to toaster ovens' average 1,400W, air fryers cook food so much faster that their overall energy consumption is lower. The combination of rapid cooking and minimal preheating time makes air fryers the more environmentally friendly choice.

Both appliances use approximately 40-50% less energy than full-size conventional ovens. For households cooking smaller portions, either option represents significant energy savings compared to heating a large oven. However, for the fastest cooking tasks, air fryers will likely save more energy and money in the long run.

Space Requirements and Kitchen Footprint

Counter Space Comparison

Standard basket-style air fryers have a smaller footprint, typically measuring 10-12 inches in diameter and 12-14 inches tall. Their compact size makes them easy to store in cabinets when not in use, though frequent users usually keep them on the counter for convenience.

Toaster ovens and air fryer toaster oven combos are larger, typically measuring 16-21 inches wide, 12-17 inches deep, and 10-13 inches tall. This larger footprint means they occupy more permanent counter space. Most users don't store toaster ovens away between uses due to their size and weight.

The space decision often comes down to your kitchen layout and available counter area. If counter space is limited, a compact air fryer might be the better choice. If you have adequate space and want an appliance that can replace multiple devices, a toaster oven's larger footprint may be justified by its versatility.

Ease of Use and Convenience Features

Air Fryer Convenience

Air fryers offer notable convenience advantages in several areas. They heat up almost instantly, eliminating wait time before cooking begins. The simple basket design makes it easy to check cooking progress—just pull out the basket and give it a shake.

However, this ease of checking comes with a downside. Opening an air fryer during cooking causes a significant temperature drop that can affect cooking times. Most air fryers feature simple dial or digital controls with preset programs for common foods like fries, chicken, and fish.

Toaster Oven Convenience

Toaster ovens feature glass doors that let you monitor food without interrupting the cooking process. This viewing window helps prevent overcooking and allows you to check browning without temperature loss.

Toaster ovens often include more complex controls to accommodate their various functions, which can involve a steeper learning curve.

Cleaning and Maintenance

Cleaning Comparison

Air fryers are generally easier to clean than toaster ovens. Most basket-style air fryers feature removable, non-stick baskets that are dishwasher-safe. The compact size means less surface area to scrub, and the basket design contains splatter better than open racks.

Toaster ovens have more components to clean, including multiple racks, crumb trays, and a larger interior cavity. Food and grease can splatter onto walls and heating elements, creating more cleaning work. The larger size and multiple nooks and crannies mean more time spent on maintenance.

Regular cleaning is important for both appliances to prevent smoke and odors during cooking. Air fryers' simpler design and smaller size make this routine maintenance quicker and less burdensome.

Noise Levels During Operation

Noise Comparison

Air fryers produce noticeable noise during cooking due to their powerful fans. The rapid air circulation that creates crispy results also generates sound comparable to a microwave or small appliance motor. If you're sensitive to kitchen noise or cook during quiet hours, this is worth considering.

Toaster ovens operate much more quietly. Models without convection fans are nearly silent, while convection toaster ovens produce gentle fan noise that's considerably quieter than air fryers. For open-concept living spaces or early-morning cooking, this noise difference can be significant.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose Air Fryer If:

✓You prioritize crispy, fried-style foods
✓Fastest cooking times matter most
✓You cook for 1-4 people regularly
✓Counter space is limited
✓Easy cleanup is important
✓You want the most affordable option

Choose Toaster Oven If:

✓You need versatile cooking functions including toasting
✓Larger capacity for families or batch cooking matters
✓You frequently bake or roast larger items
✓Quieter operation is preferred
✓You don't mind slightly slower cooking times
✓You want to consolidate multiple appliances

Professional Perspective: Many households find value in owning both a small air fryer for quick, crispy snacks and a toaster oven for versatile cooking tasks. This combination provides maximum flexibility without requiring an expensive hybrid unit.

Recommended Products

For those interested in air frying performance, the Ninja Air Fryer AF101 delivers excellent results at a reasonable price. It's compact, powerful, and perfect for achieving crispy textures with minimal oil.

If versatility matters more, consider the Black+Decker Toaster Oven with convection capabilities. It handles everything from toasting to baking to air frying in one appliance.

Browse our full selection of kitchen appliances for more options.

Common Questions

Can a toaster oven replace an air fryer?

A toaster oven can perform many of the same tasks as an air fryer, but it won't achieve the same level of crispiness or speed. While convection toaster ovens circulate hot air, their fans are less powerful and their larger chambers create less concentrated heat. Testing shows dedicated air fryers cook up to 40% faster and produce noticeably crispier results than toaster ovens. If ultimate crispiness is your priority, a toaster oven cannot fully replace an air fryer.

Which is healthier: air fryer or toaster oven?

Both air fryers and toaster ovens are healthier than deep frying since they use minimal to no oil. Air fryers typically require slightly less oil than toaster ovens to achieve crispy textures, making them marginally healthier for fried-style foods. However, the health difference between air-fried and toaster oven-baked foods is negligible compared to the dramatic improvement both offer over traditional deep frying.

Do air fryers use more electricity than toaster ovens?

Air fryers consume higher wattage (around 1,600W) compared to toaster ovens (around 1,400W), but they're actually more energy-efficient overall. Because air fryers cook food so much faster and require no preheating, their total energy consumption is lower. Air fryers typically save more money on electricity bills in the long run despite their higher power draw.

What cooks better in an air fryer than a toaster oven?

Air fryers excel at foods that benefit from maximum crispiness, including frozen french fries, chicken wings, breaded foods like chicken tenders or fish sticks, roasted vegetables that you want crispy, and reheating fried leftovers while maintaining texture. The intense air circulation and concentrated heat in air fryers create superior browning and crisping compared to toaster ovens.

Can you toast bread in an air fryer?

Air fryers are not designed to toast bread and don't perform this task well. While you can technically heat bread in an air fryer, you won't get the even, golden-brown results that toasters and toaster ovens provide. If you regularly eat toast, bagels, or English muffins, a toaster oven is the better choice or you should keep a separate toaster.

Are air fryer toaster oven combos worth the extra cost?

Air fryer toaster oven combos cost significantly more than standalone air fryers—often $100-$300 more for quality models. They're worth the investment if you have adequate counter space, need larger cooking capacity for families, want toasting capability alongside air frying, and prefer consolidating appliances. However, testing shows that even premium combos don't air fry quite as well as dedicated basket-style air fryers.

How much counter space do air fryers and toaster ovens require?

Standard basket-style air fryers require approximately 10-12 inches of counter space in diameter with 12-14 inches of height. Toaster ovens and air fryer toaster oven combos need 16-21 inches of width, 12-17 inches of depth, and 10-13 inches of height. Both appliances need several inches of clearance on all sides for proper ventilation and heat dissipation.

Which is easier to clean: air fryer or toaster oven?

Air fryers are generally easier to clean due to their simpler design and smaller size. Most feature dishwasher-safe, non-stick baskets that contain splatter well. Toaster ovens have more components including multiple racks, crumb trays, and larger interior surfaces where grease and food can splatter. The additional nooks and crannies in toaster ovens require more cleaning effort.

Can you bake in an air fryer?

Yes, you can bake in an air fryer, but with limitations. The small basket size restricts you to smaller portions and pans, and the intense air circulation can cause uneven browning on delicate baked goods. Toaster ovens provide more oven-like conditions with gentler heat circulation that's better suited for cakes, cookies, and breads. For serious baking, a toaster oven is the better choice.

How long do air fryers and toaster ovens typically last?

With proper care and regular cleaning, both appliances typically last 3-5 years of regular use. Factors affecting lifespan include build quality, frequency of use, and maintenance practices. Higher-end models from reputable brands often last longer than budget options. Regular cleaning prevents buildup that can damage heating elements and fans, extending the life of either appliance.

Professional Kitchen Essentials

The 11 Tools I Use Most in My Home Kitchen

My daily workhorse tools from 24 years in professional kitchens

⭐24 Years Professional✓11 Tools. That's It.

What You'll Get (FREE Guide):

5 Victorinox knives: Chef's (8" & 10"), paring, boning, and bread knife
Essential prep tools: Peeler, bench scraper, tongs, and mandoline
Restaurant towels: The exact bar mops I've used for decades
Professional cutting board: Epicurean board built to last
Why I chose each one: Real stories from 24 years of professional cooking

No spam, unsubscribe anytime

Your email is safeEquipment insights & reviewsInstant download

About Scott Bradley

Professional Chef • 24 Years Professional Kitchen Experience

Professional chef with 24 years of restaurant experience including Pizzaiolo at Purple Café, Kitchen Manager at Mellow Mushroom, and line positions at Feierabend, Il Pizzaiolo, and Paragary's. A.A.S. Culinary Arts from Seattle Central College, B.S. Business Administration from University of Montana. Every product tested through real professional kitchen use or extensive long-term home testing.